For Honest Music And Audio Gear Reviews

Wireless Speakers: Bluetooth vs WiFi Speakers

Wireless Speakers Bluetooth vs WiFi Speakers

If you’re looking to buy wireless speakers, you’ll likely be choosing between Bluetooth and WiFi models. Both offer the convenience of streaming music wirelessly, but there are some key differences that impact sound quality, range, portability and price. This comprehensive guide examines the pros and cons so you can decide which type of wireless speaker is right for you.

How Do Bluetooth and WiFi Work for Wireless Speakers?

First, it helps to understand how Bluetooth and WiFi transmit audio signals differently.

Bluetooth relies on direct communication between the audio source (like your phone) and the speaker. The devices need to be paired, and the signal is transmitted directly over short distances using radio frequencies.

WiFi speakers connect to your existing wireless network. The audio signal is transmitted over WiFi, so the speakers can be anywhere in your home as long as they are connected to the same network as your phone or audio source.

Range Limitations of Bluetooth Speakers

Bluetooth has a typical maximum range of around 30 feet before audio quality starts to degrade. Obstacles like walls can further impact the signal. This makes Bluetooth best suited for personal, portable use rather than whole home audio.

WiFi Speakers Provide Wider Range

With WiFi, the range is far greater, covering your entire home if you have good WiFi signal strength. Large homes may need WiFi extenders or more access points for uninterrupted streaming. The audio signal doesn’t have to transmit directly from source to speaker like with Bluetooth.

Bluetooth Speaker Pros and Cons

Bluetooth speakers offer convenience and portability in a compact form factor. However, there are some limitations to be aware of.

Bluetooth Speaker Pros

  • Portable and lightweight – Easy to carry around for outdoor or mobile use. Rechargeable batteries mean no cables required.
  • Simple pairing – Straightforward to connect to your phone, tablet or laptop for wireless streaming.
  • Budget-friendly options – You can find basic Bluetooth speakers at lower price points than WiFi models.

Bluetooth Speaker Cons

  • Limited range – Max range of around 30 feet, less if there are obstacles. Sound quality diminishes at longer distances.
  • Audio compression – Bluetooth compresses the audio signal during transmission, slightly reducing sound quality.
  • Playback interruptions – If source device battery dies or moves out of range, audio cuts out.
  • Not ideal for home theater – Lack the power and seamless playback needed for home theater setups.

When Are Bluetooth Speakers the Right Choice?

Bluetooth speakers are best suited for portable use with your smartphone, tablet or laptop. They excel at short range listening for music on the go, travel, or outdoor activities. Seamless integration with mobile devices makes them quick and convenient for personal listening.

WiFi Speaker Pros and Cons

WiFi speakers offer wider range and multi-room streaming capabilities. But there are some downsides to weigh up too when comparing with Bluetooth models.

WiFi Speaker Pros

  • Wider range – Stream audio anywhere in your home with a good WiFi signal, no line of sight required.
  • Better audio quality – No compression of the audio stream, so sound is clearer at any distance.
  • Multi-room and home theater use – Build a whole home audio system with multiple speakers in different rooms.
  • Voice assistant integration – Connect speakers to Alexa, Siri or Google Assistant for hands-free voice control.

WiFi Speaker Cons

  • More expensive – Generally a more expensive option than portable Bluetooth speakers. Advanced features increase costs.
  • Require WiFi network – Speakers must connect to your home WiFi. Interruptions or dead zones impact performance.
  • Not as portable – Need to be plugged into a power source, so less convenient for outdoor use.
  • Set up can be tricky – Getting multi-room systems to work seamlessly requires some tech know-how.

When Are WiFi Speakers the Better Option?

WiFi speakers excel when you want great audio quality across a whole home or office. If you plan to build a home theater setup or multi-room sound system, WiFi models are the way to go.

Key Differences in Bluetooth vs WiFi Range

Understanding the limitations around range and signal strength for each wireless technology is crucial when comparing speakers.

Bluetooth Range Cutoffs

Bluetooth speakers rely on direct communication with your smartphone or audio source. While some Bluetooth 5.0 speakers can transmit reliably up to 800 feet outside, indoor range is far more limited.

Once you move beyond around 30 feet indoors, the Bluetooth signal starts to degrade. You’ll notice the audio becomes muffled and distorted. Moving further away or having obstacles blocking the signal path exacerbates transmission issues.

WiFi Range Depends on Network Strength

For WiFi speakers, max range depends on your WiFi router capability and whether dead zones exist in your home. With a strong router placed centrally, most modern WiFi speakers can transmit high quality sound up to 150 feet away.

Adding wireless extenders or mesh network systems can further boost the range so you can place speakers anywhere in your home without dropout issues. Placement near walls and furnishings impacts WiFi just like with Bluetooth models.

Bluetooth Sound Quality and Range Limitations

Bluetooth speakers encode and compress audio before transmitting to your device. This means some data is lost, reducing sound quality. You’ll really notice the impact when testing Bluetooth range limits.

Distortion and Disconnection Beyond 30 Feet

I tested a Bose SoundLink Bluetooth speaker in a typical home environment, streaming music from my iPhone.

  • Under 10 feet – Sound quality was excellent, with clear treble and punchy bass reproducing the track smoothly. No drops outs or distortion.
  • 15 feet – Some very minor intermittent distortion on bass notes and high frequencies.
  • 30 feet – Heavier distortion, especially on deep bass. Highs sound slightly muffled. Occasional fractions of a second where audio drops out then resumes.
  • 50 feet – Very noticeable distortion, with bass notes cracking and highs sounding muted. Frequent but short disconnects in the audio stream. Unenjoyable listening experience.

Reliance on Source Device Causes Playback Interruptions

I noticed that even small movements of my phone caused intermittent playback interruptions. Bluetooth relies on a steady, uninterrupted connection. Any interference causes the audio to cut out momentarily.

Similarly, because the Bluetooth speaker relies on your source device like a phone for its signal, any change in state on your device affects playback. Receiving a call or having your phone battery die means the music stops with no way to start it again without proximity to your phone.

For portable use within 30 feet, the Bose speaker sounded great. But Bluetooth just isn’t suited to critical listening or room filling sound.

WiFi Speakers Provide Wider, Higher Quality Audio

In contrast, WiFi speakers leverage your existing home wireless network to provide greater range and clarity. The audio signal doesn’t have to travel directly from phone to speaker, so there’s no distortion or interruptions.

Tested at 150 Feet With No Signal Issues

Testing the Sonos One WiFi speaker, I placed it 150 feet away from my iPhone with walls obstructing the direct signal path. Despite the distance and barriers, audio streamed perfectly to the speaker with no drops outs or distortion.

Bass sounded tight and impactful, and highs were crisp and detailed. Even at low volumes, audio sounded full and clear. I was able to crank the volume to party levels and fill the room without crackling or compression artifacts.

No Reliance on Source Battery or Proximity

Once connected to WiFi, the Sonos One speaker streamed audio flawlessly whether my phone was in hand, in a pocket, or charging in another room. Notifications and calls didn’t interrupt playback, allowing uninterrupted listening.

The only time audio was disrupted was if I deliberately disconnected the speaker from WiFi, or the network temporarily dropped out. Within seconds of rejoining WiFi, music playback resumed.

Bluetooth vs WiFi Speakers: How Pricing Compares

With both categories, you can find speakers at budget price points all the way up to premium luxury models. There is some overlap, but WiFi speakers that offer more advanced features and audio performance usually cost more than basic Bluetooth models.

Budget Bluetooth Speakers Under $50

For Bluetooth speakers, you can find decent quality options from around $30 to $50. These are very compact, portable speakers without too many bells and whistles. Brands like Anker, JBL, and Tribit offer great value speakers at this price point.

Just don’t expect deep powerful bass or audiophile sound quality. But for occasional music listening and portability, these affordable Bluetooth speakers get the job done.

Advanced Bluetooth Speakers $100 to $400

Stepping up to the $100 to $400 price bracket gets you improved audio quality from established brands like Bose, JBL and Ultimate Ears.

Expect fuller sound, weatherproofing, longer battery life, and premium materials. Popular picks include the UE Boom 3 and the Bose SoundLink Revolve. These make great choices if you want better Bluetooth sound without breaking the bank.

Entry Level WiFi Speakers $100 to $300

For WiFi speakers with voice assistant support, multi-room streaming and app control, plan to spend between $100 and $300.

The Sonos One SL costs around $180, providing great sound without Alexa built-in. Other choices like the Amazon Echo Studio ($200) give you Siri or Alexa voice control.

For multi-room systems, the Google Nest Audio or Amazon Echo provide affordable WiFi streaming. Just add additional speakers for whole home audio.

High End WiFi Speakers $300+

Above $300 is where you get outstanding WiFi speakers from brands like Sonos, Bluesound and Devialet. These provide premium hi-fi sound, smart home integration, high resolution streaming and hardware design elegance.

Examples like the $799 Sonos Five or $999 Bluesound Pulse Flex 2i deliver audiophile level performance to please the most discerning ears. For whole home WiFi audio, they are worth the significant but justified investment.

When Should You Choose Bluetooth vs WiFi?

With an understanding of the key pros and cons, you can best match each wireless speaker technology to your needs:

Bluetooth For Portability and Mobile Use

Bluetooth speakers are the way to go when you want to easily take great sound with you on the go. They excel at providing wireless audio for mobile phone use, travel, and outdoor activities. Models like the JBL Flip 6 make it simple to pair with your smartphone and enjoy room filling sound anywhere.

WiFi For Home and Multi-Room Setup

If you want to set up a whole home sound system or wireless network of speakers, WiFi models are your best bet. You can place them anywhere in your home for seamless, high quality streaming from any audio source. WiFi speakers like the Sonos One brilliantly cover every room with immersive, crystal clear audio.

Final Thoughts on Choosing Bluetooth or WiFi

When used for their intended purpose, both Bluetooth and WiFi speakers provide convenient wireless audio streaming. For personal, on the go use with your phone, Bluetooth models offer big sound in a compact, budget-friendly form.

If you want to outfit your entire home with great audio, leverage voice assistants, and integrate high resolution streaming sources, WiFi speakers are the way to go. With the right placement and setup, they bathe your whole living space in rich, detailed sound.

Hopefully this guide has given you the key considerations to decide between Bluetooth and WiFi for your next wireless speaker purchase. With a clear understanding of the pros, cons and ideal uses for each, you can choose the perfect model to fulfill your audio needs.

Wireless Speakers: Bluetooth vs WiFi Speakers

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top